Compare online gold & silver buyers
Get the best deal for your gold and silver.
We track real payouts from popular US mail-in gold and silver buyers so you can see price paid per gram or per ounce, payout speed, and payment options before you decide where to ship.
CashCrowds compares buyers independently. If you buy through our links, we may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you.
Gold buyers
BrightMint Refining
$62.10 / g
Price paid*
- Payout time
- Same day after arrival
- Insurance
- $1,500 included
- Price match
- Yes
- Reviews
- 1,305 reviews
- Payment methods
- Bank transfer, PayPal, Check
MetroGold USA
$59.40 / g
Price paid*
- Payout time
- 1 business day
- Insurance
- $1,000 included
- Price match
- No
- Reviews
- 842 reviews
- Payment methods
- Bank transfer, Check
Stateside Gold Mail-In
$55.80 / g
Price paid*
- Payout time
- 2–3 business days
- Insurance
- $750 included
- Price match
- No
- Reviews
- 412 reviews
- Payment methods
- Bank transfer, Check
Frontier Cash for Gold
$51.20 / g
Price paid*
- Payout time
- 3–5 business days
- Insurance
- $500 included
- Price match
- No
- Reviews
- 233 reviews
- Payment methods
- Bank transfer, Check
Silver buyers
Liberty Silver Mail-In
$26.40 / oz
Price paid*
- Payout time
- Same day after arrival
- Insurance
- $1,000 included
- Price match
- Yes
- Reviews
- 624 reviews
- Payment methods
- Bank transfer, Check
American Coin & Silver
$25.10 / oz
Price paid*
- Payout time
- 1–2 business days
- Insurance
- $750 included
- Price match
- No
- Reviews
- 389 reviews
- Payment methods
- Bank transfer, PayPal, Check
National Silver Buyers
$24.40 / oz
Price paid*
- Payout time
- 3 business days
- Insurance
- $500 included
- Price match
- No
- Reviews
- 211 reviews
- Payment methods
- Bank transfer, Check
Get the best price for your gold and silver – independent research into the US mail-in precious metals market
Welcome to CashCrowds – an independent comparison site for US mail-in gold and silver buyers. We compare leading postal gold and silver buyers so you can see who pays fairly, who pays fast, and who gives you the best information up front. Our goal is simple: help you get the best value for your unwanted gold and silver, with full transparency.
We’ve built this resource to give anyone selling gold or silver online the clearest picture possible. That means not only how much you can expect to get per gram (gold) or per ounce (silver), but how each buyer works, what to expect when you ship, and who we believe offers the best combination of price, speed, and trust. We want you to go in informed – not guessing.
We’ve outlined how we put our comparison together so you can see our approach. We think it’s important for anyone selling gold or silver to know what to look for, how to compare offers fairly, and which companies consistently rank well on price paid, payout speed, insurance, and reviews. Our tables are based on real-world payouts and current terms; we don’t take payment for placement.
We aim to update our comparison over time with more mail-in gold and silver buyers so we keep giving visitors the best possible information to get the best price and the best deal – whether you’re selling jewelry, coins, or scrap.
Be aware that the price of gold and silver changes constantly. Our analysis uses comparable examples and timing so we can give a fair side-by-side view. Always get a current quote from the buyer’s website and read recent reviews before you ship. Use our tables as your starting point, then choose the option that fits you best.
Disclosure & important information
This comparison is for informational purposes only and is not financial, investment, or legal advice. Prices shown are illustrative examples for 14K gold per gram or silver per ounce in USD and can change based on spot price, weight, condition, and market conditions. Always verify current offers, terms, and review scores directly with each buyer before you ship. We may earn a commission from some links at no extra cost to you. Review data, including Trustpilot-style scores, is based on publicly available information as of March 17, 2026. Last updated: March 17, 2026.